Skip to main content
·

Loro Piana: Dutch Court Refuses to Protect the White Sole

A court in Utrecht has rejected Loro Piana’s bid to stop Icon Amsterdam selling a loafer with a white sole much like its own. The judge found the house had not shown that the sole is an original creation protected by copyright.

Eva Winterer

Loro Piana has lost a summary case in the Netherlands over the white sole of its best-known loafers. On 4 November the Rechtbank Midden-Nederland, sitting in Utrecht, rejected all its claims against SUJ B.V., which trades as Icon Amsterdam, including a ban on sales of its loafer “The Classic”.

The judge accepted that the two soles look very similar. Similarity alone, the ruling says, does not make a copyright infringement. Loro Piana had not shown concretely which creative choices shaped its sole and gave it an original character. The house, owned by LVMH, must pay Icon Amsterdam’s costs of €18,722.

● In brief

The claim. Loro Piana says it first used the sole between 2002 and 2005. It pointed to a horizontal groove around the sole, a slightly curved heel, a low, flat arch and a slightly translucent, off-white material.

The test. The court applied the standard set by the Court of Justice of the European Union in the Mio and Konektra cases in December 2025. An everyday object is protected by copyright only if its maker made free and creative choices that reflect his or her personality. A free choice is not enough on its own, and beauty plays no part. The Dutch judge added that a pursuit of understated luxury does not count, because a style as such is not protected.

Elsewhere. Italian courts have ruled for Loro Piana. In May a court in Turin ordered the French online seller Parijan to stop selling shoes that imitated the Summer Walk and the Open Walk, models from 2003 and 2005. Earlier, a court in Bari ruled for Loro Piana against Mnswr Group.

The shoe. Loro Piana designed the white sole for sailing, so that it leaves no marks on a deck. In the United States a suede Summer Walk costs from $1,150, and versions in alligator cost more than $11,000.

Loro Piana’s “Master of Cashmere” display: raw cashmere under a brass magnifier, the house’s name on the wall, and fibre in wooden drawers. Courtesy of Loro Piana
Loro Piana’s “Master of Cashmere” display, with raw cashmere and the house’s name. Courtesy of Loro Piana

● Why it matters

The ruling separates a house’s look from a creative work. Loro Piana based every claim on copyright, and the court never had to decide whether the house holds the rights at all, because the sole failed the originality test first.

Protection for a design depends on the country and on the case a house can make. The Turin court looked at the overall appearance of the shoes and at buyers who would take Parijan’s as cheaper versions. The Dutch court asked for proof of specific creative choices in the sole itself. Shoes have been tested this way before. In February 2025 Germany’s Federal Court of Justice ruled that Birkenstock sandals are not protected by copyright, while the same Dutch court found for Birkenstock against the retailer Scapino in November 2025.

The decision was given in summary proceedings. An appeal, or a full case on the merits, remains open to Loro Piana.

Sources